• Plum Tomatoes

    is a family owned business. For over 25 years, we have been providing excellent food, moderately priced with exceptional service! We are committed to using only the freshest, finest ingredients available to us.

Providing Pizza, Pasta, and Beer in Belle Harbor, NY for over 25 years!

At Plum Tomatoes every pizza and dish is made to order; nothing is processed or pre-cooked. We strive to make every dining experience a memorable one. Whether dining in, delivered, or using our extensive in-house or take-out catering service, we do our very best to give our customers the highest quality food with the friendliest service.


Benny and Sal, the owners and operators of Plum Tomatoes Restaurant, have been in the restaurant business for over 30 years. Growing up, as small boys in Brooklyn, they were both very influenced by family members who were lifelong restaurateurs. In 1981, they joined partnership with 2 friends and opened their first pizzeria, in Westchester, NY.


420 Beach 129th Street, Belle Harbor, N.Y. 11694 • Ph: 718-474-1775